top of page



The Tonio's Era began over 20 years ago with our Pizzeria in Avalon, New Jersey. 10 years ago, we opened up our sister restaurant along side the pizzeria, Tonio's Seafood Shack. We knew we had to share our love of the freshest seafood and best ingredients with the Florida Keys. So we decided to open Tonio's Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar right after being hit by Hurricane Irma in 2017.

Shrimp Alfredo.JPG

We promise you will feel right at home at Tonio's. Whether you are here for a family dinner or a good time with your closest friends, we strive to provide exceptional service, comforting accommodations, mouth-watering meals, refreshing beverages and an unforgettable experience.


We take great pride in offering the freshest seafood in the Florida Keys.

Our chefs are more than happy to make your taste buds smile. 

Be sure to check out our happy hour specials and live music schedule.

bottom of page